Question:
how can i discipline my 3 year old?
jamie c
2012-01-23 09:14:42 UTC
My 3 year old boy has become so out of control and does not want to mind lately. We had a new baby about 3 months ago or so and my husband and i expected jealousy of course, we would be stupid to think he wouldn't be jealous. He is really good with his little sister though, saying he loves her and always wanting to kiss her and help out. He is just a wild 3 year old little boy...running, climbing, jumping on furniture, etc.. I find myself screaming at him constantly to stop so he does not get hurt, which usually happens before he stops. He just refuses to listen or mind. I have tried everything..spankings (which i do not want to do), threatening, yelling, time out, taking toys away..nothing works. It just sparks another tantrum which wakes my newborn, which makes me even more frustrated. Also, he can play by himself in his room all day, will not let me near him, until i am feeding the baby or something...like he can go 2 hrs not wanting a drink then i ask him if he wants something because i am about to feed his sister and wont be able to get it, he will say no he is fine. then as soon as the bottle goes in her mouth he is screaming and crying he wants milk. i know he is wanting attention and we are willing to give it, but when we try he wont let us. my husband works 60 hrs a week so it's just me mainly, when he gets home i am so tired of yelling i just hand them over to him and go to bed. i cant handle his behavior lately. like honestly i do not care that he jumps on my couch...i just dont want him getting hurt. you cant make a 3 yr old understand that. i am so tired of yelling at him because i know it will linger with him and effect him. i dont want him to be scared of me. please help!!!! how do you discipline your toddlers??? also before anyone suggests ADHD i do not believe in it..i am not going to medicate my child for being a 3 year old boy just so i can get peace and quiet. i just want to know what i can try so that he knows limits and what he can and cant do.
Nine answers:
?
2012-01-23 10:15:00 UTC
Here's how to use positive parenting, or Gentle Guidance, to raise an amazing, emotionally intelligent, child.



1. Positive parenting starts by creating a good relationship with your child, so that he responds to gentle guidance as opposed to threats and punishment. The most effective discipline strategy is having a close bond with your child. Kids who feel connected to their parents naturally want to please them.



2. Evaluate all teaching based on whether it strengthens or weakens your relationship with your child. Think Loving Guidance, not punishment. Punishment is destructive to your relationship with your child and ultimately creates more misbehavior. Loving guidance is setting limits and reinforcing expectations as necessary, but in an empathic way that helps the child focus on improving her behavior rather than on being angry at you.



3. Start all correction by reaffirming the connection. Remember that children misbehave when they feel bad about themselves and disconnected from us.



Stoop down to her level and look her in the eye: "You are mad but no biting!"

Pick her up: "You wish you could play longer but it's time for bed."

Make loving eye contact: "You are so upset right now."

Put your hand on her shoulder: "You're scared to tell me about the cookie."





4. Don't hesitate to set limits as necessary, but set them with empathy. Of course you need to enforce your rules. But you can also acknowledge her perspective. When kids feel understood, they're more able to accept our limits.



"You’re very very mad and hurt, but we don’t bite. Let’s use your words to tell your brother how you feel."



5. In any situation posing physical danger, intervene immediately to set limits, but simultaneously connect by empathizing. "The rule is no hitting, even though she made you really mad by teasing like that. Let's sit down and talk about this."



6. Defiance is always a relationship problem. If your child does not accept your direction ("I don't care what you say, you can't make me!"), it's always an indication that the relationship is not strong enough to support the teaching. This happens to all of us from time to time. At that point, stop and think about how to strengthen the relationship, not how to make the child "mind." Turning the situation into a power struggle will just deepen the rift between you.



7. Avoid Timeouts. They create more misbehavior. Timeouts, while infinitely better than hitting, are just another version of punishment by banishment and humiliation. They leave kids alone to manage their tangled-up emotions, so they undermine emotional intelligence. They erode, rather than strengthening, your relationship with your child. They set up a power struggle. And they only work while you're bigger. They're a more humane form of bullying than physical discipline.



result and a signal that you need to come up with another strategy.



9. What you think and feel is more important than what you say in how your child responds.Kids will do almost anything we request if we make the request with a loving heart. Find a way to say YES instead of NO even while you set your limit. "YES, it's time to clean up, and YES I will help you and YES we can leave your tower up and YES you can growl about it and YES if we hurry we can read an extra story and YES we can make this fun and YES I adore you and YES how did I get so lucky to be your parent? YES!" Your child will respond with the generosity of spirit that matches yours.



10. How you treat your child is how she will learn to treat herself. If you're harsh with her, she'll be harsh with herself. If you're loving with her while firm about setting appropriate limits, she'll develop the ability to set firm but loving limits on her own behavior.
SkyCat2
2012-01-23 11:19:39 UTC
I wish I had an answer but mostly I just wanted to say that we are in the same boat except that we don't have a new baby, just our almost-three toddler. Lately he doesn't listen, he throws things and even hits sometimes but mostly we're concerned about him hitting us or hurting someone from throwing things. I'm guessing this is an especially bad age for boys even more so. I have never had to deal with this and I did not do this as a toddler. We just keep trying distraction from the bad activity and sometimes ignoring but if it's dangerous just repeating that we don't do that and removing toys and time outs, etc. I feel your pain, I am at my wits end also! Take care and good luck. Hang in there!
?
2012-01-23 10:20:05 UTC
Along with asrai and jocee's excellent advice -- read through



"Something Better Than Punishment"

http://www.aces.edu/pubs/docs/H/HE-0687/



"Building a Positive Relationship with Your Child"

http://www.aces.edu/pubs/docs/H/HE-0684/



"Am I Spoiling My Child?"

http://www.aces.edu/pubs/docs/H/HE-0718/



"Helping Young Children Behave"

http://www.aces.edu/pubs/docs/H/HE-0719/



http://www.awareparenting.com/timeout.htm



...you have to recognise that you are not disciplining at all, just engaging in petty battles and punishing, punishing, punishing, and the punishing isn't working at all. Re-think EVERYTHING about your relationship with your child; right now, it is awful, and his behaviour is the natural outcome of that.



With a POSITIVE relationship with your child, with positive discipline instead of punishment, you will have a good relationship with him; you will actually be able to say: we can't jump on that because [dangerous, point out sharp corners on nearby coffee table or whatever], and since your child loves you and wants to please you and you're an authority figure who is an ALLY instead of an authority figure who is an violent, screaming BULLY, he _will_ listen. Right now you are fighting with your child -- don't fight with your child!
?
2016-11-02 01:43:43 UTC
3 Year Old Discipline Techniques
2016-03-02 02:10:15 UTC
The time out is definitely the way to go. Sit her down somewhere like in the living room or the kitchen and then walk away from her, but make sure you are somewhere where you can see her and she can't see you. Then you can keep an eye on her and make sure she stays put. Let her cry her little eyes out, and once she is finished, then you go up to her with a calm yet stern voice and tell her what she did wrong and encourage her to apologize. You just have to BE the mom, be the rule maker and be someone she can learn to respect, even if she is feeling upset. And of course, once everything has been sorted out, lots of love is the best remedy! Good luck!
jocee
2012-01-23 09:34:19 UTC
I don't think it's a discipline problem at all. I'd try to get someone over to help out, either giving your son positive attention or watching baby while you play with your son. Baby proof your house to minimize accidents and just try to relax and see his behaviour as quite normal. There's no way I'd be doing spanking, timeouts or lots of shouting. He's trying to adjust to a new sibling and those discipline techniques will just make him resent you even more. What's more he probably thinks that you don't love him as much anymore and those discipline techniques will confirm that in his mind. It's an attention problem, and there's only one of you, so try to get more help.
2012-01-23 09:49:22 UTC
i had this problem with my daughter nothing would work! but i found since she has started going to pre school her behavior has improved allot! and since i stopped buying sweets n crisps she has improved. now i say i will take a toy away but gotta follow through with it. i think its because children don't respect their parents listed or take them as seriously as other adults so pre school helps as they learn to copy other children and listen more as is probably more fun and interesting.
Ivy has Twin Boys!
2012-01-23 11:02:24 UTC
I agree with Chastity, Proper Time-outs.



Put him on a mat (or chair, step whatever, we use a mat) and make him stay there while calm for 3 minutes. It may take 5 hours to get him to take a 3 minute time out at first, but over time he'll get better at it.



he may repeat the behavior, if so, repeat the time-out. This is what most people would advocate for a case like this.



It is going to be difficult. There isn't an easy fix. If you REALLY need him to lay off for awhile you can do a time-out by locking him in a room for a few minutes (you can get a high up latch for the outside of the door), but this is more for your sanity (and so you are not screaming at him or hitting him in frustration) then to discipline him. He is big enough to get out of a crib, and if you need to feed the baby and he isn't allowing it locking him in a room if he isn't allowing the baby to be fed may be an alternative. I'm not there to see how bad his behavior is, but obviously, you do need to be able to feed your younger child.



After that you should probably still follow up with a proper time out, as locking him in the room may not make him calm.



I agree you should stop yelling at him, but you know that. Whatever you decide to do, try to do it calmly. Make sure he is getting enough attention at other times. Offer him attention at other times, and warn him ahead of time you are going to be offlimits when it is time to feed the younger child.



I also agree with no sugar and also preschool if it is an option for you. He may take discipline better coming from someone else. Some schools offer a lot of structure, and he may benefit a lot from it. Preschool would provide a break for both of you, since he is obviously having trouble having the baby in the house, and you are having some trouble with him right now.
Chasity
2012-01-23 09:35:22 UTC
Time out is a great technique for disipline

Step 1: A warning in a firm tone

Step 2 : place child in naughty spot / bench

Step 3: leave child one min per age of life (3 mins)

If they try to get up then place them back on it gently without speaking (expect screaming)

Step 4: Explain what the child did wrong and ask for an apology then hugs and kisses



The technique should work, but only when done properly, it can be very time consuming at first as children aren't used to it, but it works only if you stick to it.

Because you have a newborn too it may be hard at first, because the child will keep getting up, but perservere. If the child runs off wait for them to come back, its much easier.

Expect running off, and time consuming.



Screaming at the child will only make the situation worse- children learn through immitation so he will learn this is how to behave when mad, but he's only 3 so this can be changed.



Also have a reward system in place, like balls in a jar, when he does a good behaviour a ball goes into a jar when hes got so many he gets a treat like a small toy

Other ideas are stickers on a chart



Hope ive helped

Ps Congratulations on not smacking, parenting through fear doesnt work


This content was originally posted on Y! Answers, a Q&A website that shut down in 2021.
Loading...